Skip to main content

Broker commission litigation

Straw Broker Schemes: When Your Commission Is Diverted

A disputed broker designation requires review of the agreement, transaction history and payment records. Another broker being identified does not alone establish wrongdoing or a right to a commission. These schemes often overlap with procuring cause disputes about who actually earned the commission.

Warning signs of a straw broker

Sudden "no longer interested"

Your client walks away, then an offer on the same property appears hours or days later through someone else.

Changed broker designation

Preserve the earlier and later versions of transaction documents showing which broker was identified.

New or unformed LLC

The purchaser is an entity created after you introduced the buyer, sometimes not yet legally formed at signing.

Same price you negotiated

The deal closes at terms that match pricing information you obtained and shared.

How a straw broker scheme usually works

In the cases we see, the pattern is familiar. An agent introduces a buyer to a property, shows it, and does the work that moves the buyer toward a deal. Then, close to contract, a different name appears on the paperwork: a relative's brokerage, a newly licensed friend, or an agent who never met the buyer. The commission is paid to that broker, and some or all of it flows back to the people who arranged the switch. Sometimes the buyer receives a rebate or a lower price in exchange. On paper the deal looks ordinary. In substance, the broker who did the work was cut out.

Where the evidence usually turns up

  • The settlement statement and the commission disbursement authorization, which show who was paid and how much.
  • The purchase contract and any buyer brokerage agreement, including the dates they were signed.
  • Showing records, showing-service or lockbox logs, and MLS activity that tie your work to the property.
  • Texts and emails with the buyer, the listing agent and the seller, especially around the time the buyer went quiet.
  • Public records: the paid agent's license history on the DBPR license lookup, company filings on Sunbiz, and the recorded deed.
  • Payment trails, which usually come out in discovery once a lawsuit is filed.

How this connects to procuring cause

A straw broker scheme is usually built to defeat a procuring cause claim. If you started the chain of events that led to the sale, a last-minute change in the paperwork does not by itself decide who earned the commission. Our guide to procuring cause explains how Florida brokers prove they earned the fee. When the switch was planned and the money was shared, the facts may also support fraud and civil conspiracy claims against people who never signed your agreement.

What to do now

  1. Write down a timeline while it is fresh: first contact, every showing, every conversation about an offer.
  2. Save texts, emails, showing logs and MLS history. Do not delete anything.
  3. Get the recorded deed and, if you can, the settlement statement.
  4. Look up the license and brokerage history of the agent who was paid.
  5. Do not confront the buyer or the other agent in writing before you get advice. What you write can be used later.
  6. Check your listing or buyer agreement for arbitration, notice or protection period terms. Some carry short deadlines.
  7. Call us at 305-748-3789. Meetings by appointment only.

Frequently asked questions

What is a straw broker?

A straw broker is a licensee named on a transaction mainly to receive a commission that is then shared with, or returned to, a party to the deal. The broker who actually found the buyer and negotiated the terms is left out.

What legal claims can apply to a straw broker scheme?

Depending on the facts, claims may include breach of contract, procuring cause, fraud in the inducement, tortious interference with a business relationship, unjust enrichment, and civil conspiracy against everyone who participated.

Can I sue the buyer if I didn't have a written agreement with them?

Possibly. Some claims, such as fraud and tortious interference, do not depend on a written buyer agreement. Your timeline, communications, and the relationship between the parties matter. An attorney can review whether your facts support a claim.

How quickly should I act?

Florida statutes of limitations apply, and evidence like text messages and showing records can be lost. Preserve everything and seek a case review promptly.

Is a straw broker scheme the same as a procuring cause dispute?

Not exactly. A procuring cause dispute asks which broker earned the commission. A straw broker scheme adds a second question: whether people worked together to divert a commission they knew someone else had earned. The first is usually a contract claim. The second can add fraud or conspiracy claims and can reach people outside the contract.

As covered by

Law.com Daily Business Review · The Real Deal · CityBiz · RISMedia · VINnews · HousingWire · Hoodline · Law360 Real Estate Authority

View press coverage